I've been curious about why Popes (Villa Giulia was built by Pope Julius III) were so sanguine about the fashion for Roman mythical figures. Why didn't they treat statues of Zeus like statues of Baal? I gather the reason is that Christianity basically just superimposed Jesus, Mary, Saints and Popes overtop of the indigenous belief system, so the Roman and Greek gods were thought of as the cultural ancestor to Christianity. So building a reproduction temple with statues of various gods didn't count as constructing false idols. As you can see in Dante, the assumption was that if the Roman and Greek intellectuals had known about Jesus, they would have adopted Christianity. Obviously actual idolators wouldn't be able to write great philosophy and literature. So, interestingly, Popes were commissioning statues of Zeus, Minerva, Bacchus, etc. at the same time that priests in Latin America were burning Mayan books (which obviously couldn't be philosophy or literature, since they were written by idolators).
Then we went to Basilica Papale di San Paolo fuori le Mura, which is a Basillica originally built by Constantine but rebuilt several times. It is built over the grave of St. Paul.
| Stefano at cafe |
| Villa Giulia (no pics of Etruscan stuff) |
| Nyadarium (altar/temple to Nyads) Build by the Pope who built the Villa. Popes in the Renaissance treated Roman gods like cultural heritage rather than idolatry. |
| Basillica of St. Paul Past the Wall |
| It's huge. |
| Cloister/gardens at St. Paul Basillica |



Hi Peggy - interesting to reflect on the different treatment of ancient Roman/Greek deities versus how the Mayans were treated. While in divinity school, I certainly became completely aware of the overlay of early Christian theology on it's predecessors (the appropriate/assimilate approach to converting a population) - aside from the sheer convenience of doing so, it is simply more straightforward to appropriate existing practices and beliefs to a new system than have to eliminate those existing practices in favor of a new system. Christianity is just rife with pagan symbolism (in addition to the robed images you keep seeing, think of the German Christmas tree tradition for maybe the most obvious). I wonder if the differential treatment of the Mayans, however, might also have stemmed from a form of racism (oh, duh). After all, the ancient, pre-Christian Greeks and Romans could be seen as ancestrally linked to the Romans that founded the early church, while the Mayans (I assume) were seen as completely separate (ergo idolaters).
ReplyDelete